The MLB Bible Verse Controversy Wasn't About the Bible

Earlier this year, I wrote about the MLB Pride Night controversy for the Cincinnati Enquirer, focused on Vice President Vance's response and what it revealed about a particular kind of political convenience. This post picks up where that one left off. Less about any single official's reaction, more about the pattern itself and how consistently it shows up across sports, across politics, and across whichever side happens to be doing the talking that week.

A few San Francisco Giants pitchers wrote a Bible verse on their Pride Night caps earlier this year. MLB issued a routine warning for violating its uniform policy, which bars players from adding writing to their equipment regardless of the message's content. Within four days, Senator Josh Hawley had sent the commissioner a letter citing "grave concern" and a "pattern of discrimination" against Christian players. Within a week, two actors with a combined audience in the millions were publicly offering to pay any fines, the Justice Department had referred the matter to the EEOC, and multiple state attorneys general were threatening investigations of their own. The commissioner eventually clarified, in writing, that the rule was content-neutral, the players were never fined, and they never would be. By the time the dust settled, the actual story of a routine equipment warning, quickly resolved, had been almost entirely replaced by the story everyone had already decided to tell about it.

What struck me watching it unfold wasn't the controversy. It was the speed. Outrage that fast doesn't usually reflect a longstanding commitment to civil liberties. It reflects how quickly a story can become a rallying point for an audience already primed to receive it, which tells you something about the incentives at work even when it tells you very little about the principle supposedly at stake.

The pattern is familiar. People invoke free speech to defend expression they already agree with, then go quiet, or actively support punishment, when the same principle would protect speech they don't.

It reminded me of Colin Kaepernick.

Kaepernick's decision to kneel during the national anthem was quiet. It wasn't disruptive, wasn't violent, wasn't even loud. It was symbolic expression of exactly the kind that has shaped American civic life for as long as the country has existed. Many of the same voices now defending the Giants pitchers' right to write a Bible verse on their own cap were, several years ago, calling for athletes who knelt to be benched, fined, or run out of the league.

The reverse holds just as well. Plenty of people who passionately defended Kaepernick's right to protest are considerably less enthusiastic about defending a player whose protest cuts against their own politics.

The inconsistency doesn't run in only one direction. Nick Bosa wore a "Make America Great Again" hat during a live postgame broadcast, a deliberate rule violation endorsing a sitting presidential candidate rather than a quiet gesture, and was fined a few thousand dollars he later called "well worth it." Compare the outcomes. A peaceful, rule-compliant protest ended a career. A deliberate, rule-violating campaign endorsement cost less than a parking ticket relative to either player's salary. Whichever direction the inconsistency runs in a given month, it tends to track the audience a particular outrage is aimed at rather than any stable theory of what these leagues should tolerate.

I don't bring this up to score points for one side. If anything, it points to something more uncomfortable than partisanship. Our arguments about free expression tend to reveal our biases far more reliably than our principles.

Legally, none of this involves the First Amendment. MLB isn't the government. Neither is the NFL. The First Amendment restrains state action and has nothing to say about what a private organization requires of its own employees, on its own uniforms, during its own broadcasts. These leagues can set whatever rules they want, regardless of how many senators write letters about it.

But we've let that legal technicality become a moral exit ramp. "It's legal" has become the end of the conversation instead of the beginning of a different one, about what kind of civic culture we actually want to practice, separate from what the law strictly permits.

A healthy civic society should hold itself to more than the bare legal minimum. The First Amendment works better as the floor of our obligations to each other than as the ceiling. It's a framework for living alongside people who hold convictions you don't share, not a finish line you cross once a court declines to intervene.

The real question isn't whether a league has the legal right to enforce a uniform policy. It's whether we, as the people watching, reward conformity and punish dissent the instant either becomes inconvenient to our own side.

None of this means every form of expression deserves applause, or that criticism is off the table. The opposite. The healthiest response to speech you find misguided, offensive, or genuinely harmful has always been more speech: persuasion, protest, organizing, public argument. Censorship rarely changes anyone's mind. It tends to calcify the position it was meant to silence.

Sports have functioned as a stage for civic life for about as long as there have been organized sports. We ask athletes to embody resilience, sacrifice, national pride, and unity, then act surprised when the same athletes use that visibility to speak about justice, faith, identity, or conscience instead. That's not a contradiction. It's the predictable result of putting people with strong convictions in front of a national audience and asking them to mean something.

The test was never whether we agree with what a particular athlete says. It's whether we're willing to extend the same grace and the same freedom to people we disagree with that we demand for ourselves when we're the ones speaking.

Free expression is easy to defend when the speaker already confirms what you believe. It only becomes meaningful when it protects the person trying to convince you of something else.

That might be the civic muscle worth strengthening. Defending the First Amendment from government overreach is the easy, low-stakes version of the fight. The harder version is practicing the spirit of it in places the Constitution was never built to reach: living rooms, workplaces, comment sections, and ballparks. A democracy's health depends on more than the rules that govern it. It depends on the habits its people choose to practice when nobody's making them.

One of those habits is learning to defend someone else's right to say something you wish they hadn't.

I speak on First Amendment principles, civic life, and the gap between legal rights and civic responsibility at universities, civic organizations, and law schools. If these questions connect to work you're doing, simontam.org/speaking is the place to start.

Next
Next

We Don't Speak "Asian"